Viewing comments for ystuk85« back to profile

Rob Vickers cited following yellow card punch on Joe Marler

and he called it a maul! what a muppet

2 Years, 4 Months ago

O2 Inside Line - Six Nations 2012, episode 4

the english lads look like a laugh, it's a pity austin healey has to get involved. i don't think england will beat france in paris. had it been in twickenham i would have said yes, but france are always a lot harder when they play at home. not a big fan of his "we should have won", england had chances and so did wales. wales took their opportunities and there were a few poor decisions for both teams, not just england. by his logic wales should have beaten france and SA at RWC, but guess what they didn't!

2 Years, 4 Months ago

O2 Inside Line - Six Nations 2012, episode 4

bore off austin

2 Years, 4 Months ago

Wales claim the Triple Crown with nail biting win over England

roberts is only 25! you said phillips is slow but how slow is dickson at getting the ball out from the back of the ruck. i think over the next 12 months another scrum half will come to the fore (from one of the home nations), for wales i'd like to see lloyd williams given a run. im not saying he will be the lions scrum half i am saying i want him to have a few games for wales. as for picking denton ahead of faletau that's a bit bizarre, faletau was arguably the player of the world cup (86 tackles 0 missed). i would have ferris before o'brien at 6, who offers more, o'brien is primarly a carrier but hasn't carried so well this season, ferris is a lot more dynamic. i would have halfpenny at 15 too who has been faultless in the rwc and 6n, not sure who would be on the other wing...

2 Years, 4 Months ago

Wales claim the Triple Crown with nail biting win over England

ben kay wrote in an interesting piece (i think it's in the guardian), the advantage was over as strettle had crossed the line. I think you should have had a penalty from north slapping the ball into touch, but you would have more than likely kicked for a lineout so no real issue there?

2 Years, 4 Months ago

Wales claim the Triple Crown with nail biting win over England

both was tackled, placed the ball at the back of the ruck (there was english player jackling and competing against scott williams) and then pulled the ball back into the ruck. he then popped the ball up to corbisierio who was tackled by rhys priestland who was offside. however as botha was playing the ball from the floor (he didn't simply pop the ball from the tackle, he placed then regathered the ball) he should have been penalised for having hands in the ruck. to be fair though this happened so fast and I didn't really notice at the time, it's only when you watch it again that you will notice. great game though! and no try at the end!

2 Years, 4 Months ago

Richie McCaw knee on Morgan Parra, Donald kick, Rougerie eye-gouge, and more

i think the major drawback this tournament has been the standard of refereeing. there has been so much controversy surrounding referees that simply should not be there. the aim of the referee should be to remain anonymous. you should not remember the referee in the game. craig joubert in wales v ireland was like this and i think this is why he got the final. unfortunately he reffed france out of it. i can understand the french's frustration but just remember you were on the good side of the ref in the semi. and as for richie mccaw not acknowledging the french, yachvilli did exactly the same after the welsh game. so try not to forget your own history. the mccaw knee wasn't deliberate in my opinion, the rougerie gouging is disgusting and he should be banned. as for rugbydump, i don't know what nationality the site is which surely shows how impartial they are!

2 Years, 8 Months ago

 
Site Meter