Viewing comments for breakaway« back to profile

Joe Marler explains to referee that early RWC exit is reason for late tackle against Wasps

Ha Ha… excellent. It's a small moment but a nice change from the sourness of the last couple of days.

7 Months, 1 Week ago

'Penalty was the wrong call' says World Rugby review of Craig Joubert decision

I agree with pretty much everything. Also, the majority of refs would've made the same call as Joubert did in real time. There seems to an underlying assumption in so many of the complaints, that a different referee would've definitely made a different call. Nonsense. Only by examining the slo-mo do any of us know for sure that the ball brushed Phipps' arm. The vast majority of even the best refs would have made the same call as Joubert and been in the same position you describe.

7 Months, 1 Week ago

Wallabies snatch victory from courageous Scots at the death

DrG… I'm not sure what happened, my reply ended up above your post instead of below. This might too.

7 Months, 1 Week ago

Wallabies snatch victory from courageous Scots at the death

It's taken a couple of coffees, but I think I see what you're saying. Because the Scotsman grabbed the ball while offside, then maybe that constitutes deliberate foul play and can therefore be sent to the TMO. I think the law recognises the difference between instinctively grabbing at a possibly knocked-on ball (and often, who can tell?), and deliberately playing the ball while being unambiguously offside. And thank God for that. It's only on slo-mo replay that any of us knows for sure that it brushed against Phipps. My position is that the vast majority of even the very best refs would've made the same decision in real time, and players too.

7 Months, 1 Week ago

Wallabies snatch victory from courageous Scots at the death

I demand the TMO. I know it's not allowed, but this is a critical moment in my day.

7 Months, 1 Week ago

Wallabies snatch victory from courageous Scots at the death

I think you missed the intended humour. Do you truly believe I think I convinced everyone, or even anyone? pff!

7 Months, 1 Week ago

Argentina knock Ireland out with convincing Quarter Final win

*Argentina's had the packs…

7 Months, 1 Week ago

Argentina knock Ireland out with convincing Quarter Final win

Argentina's have had the packs and some good, even great, number tens for a long time, but their general back play has really sharpened up in the RCh. I'm sure the All Blacks already knew that but they were still caught on the hop when the Pumas came roaring out of the blocks in the first game. I thought the Irish might roll right back over the Pumas, once they got going, but the way Argentina took the pressure and then came again was impressive. I still think Aust in the SF, but nothing would surprise me.

7 Months, 1 Week ago

Wallabies snatch victory from courageous Scots at the death

I'm not sure why you're asking me about deliberate offside and foul play. I haven't mentioned them. I also haven't said that I'm a big fan of Joubert, in fact I've criticised the yellow card in this game and I think he got the front row penalties mostly wrong too. He has pretty ordinary days.
I'm saying that whatever the fluctuating standards of referees, individually or as a group, rugby is difficult enough to referee as it stands, even with laws mostly as clear as they can be written. It won't improve the situation by insisting that a ref has to decide whether to go to the TMO based on highly subjective ideas about whether that point in the game is crucial or important enough. Any sort of consistency would be impossible and even the decisions to go to the TMO or not every few minutes towards the end of a big match would add controversy. Nobody would be happy. The complaints would increase, not decrease. The TMO protocols are clear and Joubert followed them because he had no alternative. Frankly, I think most other top refs would've made the same decision in real time. See katman's post below, for more common sense.

7 Months, 1 Week ago

Wallabies snatch victory from courageous Scots at the death

I agree, the protocols are not designed for this situation, because they cannot be, in the way you suggest. The TMO protocols are pretty clear about the situations that can be reviewed. They have to be so that as much clarity and objectivity as possible can be brought into situations that get pretty murky and emotional.
If, as I think you're suggesting, the ref could call the TMO not based on clear rules but on subjective feelings about whether the moment is serious enough, which moment is more important than other moments in match, you're putting a huge burden on refs that they can't humanly carry without creating even more angst and controversy. It's hard enough now when the protocols are clear. It would be a nightmare to insist that refs must also decide which bit of general play is more crucial than another. When should every kickable penalty go to TMO; two minutes from the end, five minutes from the end? Only within 40 metres, 22 metres…? I see mayhem.
I'll leave the 2011 stuff. I thought I'd dealt with it on sites like this and convinced everybody four years ago. Anyway, I honestly don't think it's relevant to this situation.

7 Months, 1 Week ago