Viewing comments for Ash« back to profile

Classic Encounters - Madagascar host Namibia in epic high scoring battle

That guy @0:28 would be a great lifter in the lineout.

But seriously, this is really amazing stuff. We can sometimes think rugby is only a sport for about 14 or so countries, but when you see stuff like this it makes you really appreciate the game of rugby. I'd love to see the fans reactions to a major team visiting in some of these countries like Madagascar or even Georgia and other places where rugby is popular but the fans never get to see the best in the world play. It could really boost the games global appeal.

5 Years, 11 Months ago

John Afoa suspended for four weeks for dangerous tackle

That's a joke. I'm pretty harsh on people who commit spear tackles but to be honest I think that was pretty much fine.

6 Years, 2 Months ago

Peter Stringer commits daylight robbery on James O'Connor

Haha that's just made my day

6 Years, 6 Months ago

Sam Warburton red card in Rugby World Cup Semi Final

Personally I think it was a red card. Having been on the receiving end of similar spear tackle I know for a fact it's not so much the pain it inflicts but the risks and fear it produces. I remember at the moment of impact you do straight away fear something terrible has happened. To say like some people have suggested that as there was no injury in this type of tackle is nonsense. If someone in football/soccer lunged in two footed, late and high up on the leg and breaks the players leg then it doesn't make it less serious or less dangerous than if he'd done the same except missed. I commend the ref for finally having the courage to take a stand and take the right action against what is a very serious offence. It's not like Rolland hasn't been consistent either, he sent off Fritz (I think) for something similar in the Heineken cup earlier this year so he's being consistent and he is following the law to the letter which is correct. You can't say just because it's a semi final he should have been let off as the rules are the rules, and they apply from under 14's rugby on a Saturday morning right up to the top level of international rugby.

6 Years, 8 Months ago

Leonardo Ghiraldini in trouble after making contact with Cian Healy's eyes

When we look at precedent by the IRB (not that they ever take heed of it themselves) but in 2008 Neil Best was banned for 18 weeks for what was described by the committee as 'accidental but reckless' contact with the eyes, not specifically an eye 'gouge'.

The problem with this of course is that Burger got an 8 week ban for doing it deliberately in 2009 and Parisse got 8 weeks as well in same year. Perhaps because Ghiraldini isn't a marquee name like those two the IRB wont be afraid to give him a longer ban (though to be honest I'm still 50/50 as to whether it was deliberate or not) and take the tough stance necessary if they believe it was deliberate. I'd guess as it's not completely clear cut any ban given will be relatively short.

6 Years, 8 Months ago

The Lynx Rules to Rugby Union

God bless you Rugbydump

6 Years, 8 Months ago